?

Log in

hmd67 [userpic]
Truth or Dare
by hmd67 (hmd67)
at September 7th, 2007 (07:28 pm)

I thought I would dust off this place a little bit.

Author: Harald/Purplemage
Title: Truth or Dare
Theme: Sorry, I didn't check out the calendar for the themes >.>
Pairing: Remus/Sirius & James/Lily
Rating: NC-17
Warnings: Voyeurism, fingering, masturbation, hair-pulling, anal sex, oral sex, un-betaed
Word Count: 4512 (long, I know, but good!)
Summary: Sirius and Remus get caught by Lily and now they must do what she wants if they don't want to get kicked out of Hogwarts.
Additional Notes: I started writing this ages ago as an experiment first, I wanted to try my hand at a het pairing and second, I wanted to mix some comedy with smut. I think it turned out all right. This is the first time I write het-smut and Lily for that matter. You may find some OOC-nes.


“I pick…Sirius!” Peter announced with a smirk on his face. He was obviously pretending he didn’t know whom to choose. “Truth or dare, Sirius?”

Sirius sighed. “You know I always pick dare, Peter,” he replied, bored.

Who do I have to kiss now?

It became a costume for the older Gryffindors to play ‘Truth or dare’ in the late hours of a Friday night. The little ritual had started thanks to James who had suggested it as a ploy to kiss Lily Evans, but the plan hadn’t worked as expected.

It was the fourth Friday in a row that the game took place and still James hadn’t had a chance to kiss Lily. Licking the sole of her shoe, as a dare, was the closest thing he had come to kissing her. Each Friday, the game only got only more frustrating for James. More people joined in and the dares and truths got worse and worse. For example, nobody needed to know about Peter’s secret obsession with Madam Pomfrey.

The other marauders found James’ frustration amusing. They loved the look on his face whenever Lily chose truth over dare, which was always. Lily wasn’t dumb. She knew what James was up to, but she played coy and chose always truth with the excuse that she was scared of dares. Sometimes, Lily even played the part of being indecisive just to extend James’ seconds of agony.

Remus just got dragged, as usual. He found the game silly and immature, but deep down he had fun too. He especially enjoyed the private sessions of ‘Truth or dare’ that he played with Sirius afterwards.

Peter scanned the faces of the people gathered on the ground. The boys sitting on the circle looked impatient and most of the girls looked anxious. This might be their only chance to kiss the handsome Sirius Black. It was obvious what Peter was doing; he was looking for ugliest girl of them all and he found her.

“Sirius, I dare you to kiss Bunny!” Peter said with an evil and yet dumb grin. Instantly, Bunny flushed and Sirius wanted to die. He shot an evil glare to Peter and then looked at Bunny who was battering her eyelashes at him.

Sirius stared at Bunny’s face starting with her bushy eyebrows, her oily, zit covered skin and finally her big nose. It wasn’t that bad, he thought. He was a brave Gryffindor and could handle anything. It wasn’t until Bunny displayed her sharp, chocolate covered teeth that Sirius started thinking that maybe he wasn’t that brave.

“I need to talk to you,” he whispered into Remus’ ear. “Now!” Sirius added when Remus didn’t respond right away.

Sirius took the werewolf’s arm and forced him to stand up from the floor. He dragged him to the end of the common room and hid behind a large couch.

“What are you doing?” Remus asked with eyes widened.

“I can’t do it!” Sirius said, shaking his head. They were keeping their voices down so the people at the other end of the room wouldn’t hear them.

Remus snorted. “Sirius, you’ve kissed plain girls before.”

“Plain, I can handle, but this… this is too much,” Sirius admitted. “I felt a part of my soul dying when I looked into that girl’s mouth!”

Remus sighed, summoning some patience. “Sirius, this is not the time for your shallow pride to take action,” Remus scolded. Sirius could tell that deep down the werewolf was very amused by the situation. “You’re going to hurt that girl’s feelings if you don’t kiss her!”

“I’ll die of tetanus if I kiss her!” Sirius snapped. “Don’t you care about my health?”

Remus caressed Sirius’ shoulder to calm his irrational fear. Slowly, he got very close to Sirius face. Almost close enough for them to kiss without leaning in.

“If you do this….” Remus paused, teasing. Sirius was suddenly interested in what the werewolf was saying. “Later, when we’re both alone, in your bed…”

Sirius couldn’t resist the lustful tone in Remus’ voice. The warm breath on his face was more than enough to drive him crazy. Suddenly, Remus’ hand traveled down from Sirius’ shoulder and snaked its way to the crotch.

“Seriously, Sirius,” Remus whispered as he massaged. The erection grew under the fabric. “If you just relaxed a little bit…you’d realize how funny the situation is.”

“Pathetic…that’s what it is,” said Sirius, letting escape a small whimper. “It’s pathetic how far a bloke would go for…a good shag.”

“Now let’s go,” informed Remus, standing up and finishing the massaging session. Remus looked down at Sirius, but he wouldn’t stand up. He stayed on the floor on a crouching position. “Get up.”

Sirius smiled at his boyfriend. “I wish I could, but you’ve left me with a little present here I can’t get rid off!”


***



Later that night, Sirius was brushing his teeth like he had never done before in his life. He wanted to get every single trace of Bunny’s taste out of his mouth. Who knew the girl had such a limber tongue? And long, too!

James and Peter had gone to bed a while ago and Remus was already lying on Sirius bed. Peter’s snoring assured the couple that he was already sound asleep. James was probably still awake. Another Friday night had gone by and he still hadn’t been able to kiss Lily. He was probably upset about that, and the that he was dared to tell everyone about his embarrassing first kiss experience, and make an embarrassing impersonation of Professor McGonagall.

Sirius finally left the bathroom and was happy to see Remus all cozy in his bed.

“It’s a big bed,” Remus said. “And I’m all alone.”

Sirius grinned and jumped onto the bed. They started a romantic wrestle between the sheets trying to see who could come on top. Remus couldn’t help but laugh when Sirius started to tickle him.

“Shut the curtains!” Remus managed to say between laughs.

Sirius quickly hopped to it and cast a silencing charm while he was at it. Now they were all alone in their little private love nest. The wrestling continued and they started to rashly unbutton each other’s pajama shirts. With one swift movement, Remus was on top of Sirius. He sat on top of his hips and placed both hands on his lover’s naked chest.

“Tonight…is all about you,” he said between deep breaths. His hair was falling over his face and he carried a lustful grin.

Sirius smiled back. Without a warning, Remus leaned in a caught his boyfriend’s lips. Sirius opened his mouth and let Remus’ tongue in. As they kissed Remus played with Sirius’ nipple. Sirius’ hands traveled up and down Remus’ back sending shivers all through the werewolf’s body.

Their tongues were engaged in the most passionate of all dances and their hands were feeling each inch of each other’s bodies. It was a territory they both knew so well, but that they never got tired of visiting.

A moan escaped Sirius’ mouth when Remus’ bit his boyfriend’s lower lip. Remus went from Sirius mouth to his earlobe. He bit and sucked for a while. He then went down to Sirius’ neck where he licked, kissed, and sucked more. Sirius had a smile on his face.

Sirius’ hand traveled down Remus’ back. He finally slid his hand down his boyfriend’s pajama pants and let his finger explore between his lover’s butt cheeks. Remus’ produced a loud moan when Sirius’ finger slipped into the hole. Sirius felt Remus’ back muscles tighten when he started to enter Remus with his finger. Waves of pain and pleasure traveled through the werewolf’s body.

“Oh my God…” Remus moaned under his breath.

While Sirius was entering him, Remus reached down, slipped his hand inside Sirius’ trousers, feeling the pubic hair and started stroking his boyfriend’s erection. Sirius’ arched his neck when he felt Remus’ warm grip around the shaft. Remus’ gently took Sirius’ hand out of his own pants and slid down. He kept going down until his face was dangerously in front of Sirius’ package.

“Remember,” Remus said, locking eyes with Sirius. “Tonight, is all about you.”

With a naughty smile Remus pulled Sirius’ trousers down, slowly. Sirius helped by arching his back. His erection bounced out when the underwear was finally slipped down. Sirius erected dick was right between Remus’ eyes. Ironically, Remus’ manhood was longer. The werewolf genes, Sirius thought, but Sirius knew how to use his very well.

Sirius’ jaw fell when he felt Remus’ tongue on the base. Nice and slowly, the tongue glided upwards leaving a warm trail of saliva. Finally, Remus’ got to the head of Sirius’ dick and teased the small orifice with the tip of his tongue. Sirius had to bit his lower lip in order not to yell in pleasure. Remus kissed the head, and opened his mouth to let the full length in.

He took it all in once. Sirius was surprised. He had never done that before. Remus’ kept Sirius’ cock inside his mouth for a few seconds, and then started going up. The feeling of Remus’ lips around his cock was more that Sirius could bare. He moaned loudly and dug his fingers in the mattress. Before he knew it, Remus was going up and down his dick. Gaining pace with each suck. It was incredible! Remus had never sucked him like that before! He was in heaven. Sirius’ eyes were closed with pleasure and his mouth produced whimpers and moans. Pleading for Remus not to stop.

“Oh…God…Remus…” Sirius was in such levels of ecstasy that he couldn’t produce a full sentence.

He was close.

“Remus…”

“What in Merlin’s name…?” A female voice pierced through Sirius’ ears like a sharp needle on a gentle cloth.

The curtains slid open and a faint light showered over Sirius, blinding him, but Remus didn’t stop. He saw Lily’s shocked face, but he couldn’t help it. Remus pulled away and Sirius came all over his own chest.

A cold drop of sweat ran down Sirius forehead as he witnessed the scene. Lily stood, shocked, by the bed holding the curtains open. Remus was crouching in front of him. His dick was in full view and a trace of evidence was splattered on his stomach.

Remus was the first to react by pulling the sheets over Sirius’ privates. Lily shook her head nervously and shut the curtains close. Sirius didn’t know what to do. He wanted to laugh, cry, pass out, and thank Remus for the best fucking blowjob of his life, all at once. But he knew he had to pull himself together and chase Lily down before she told anyone what she saw. After all, she was a Headgirl, and a great one too. It didn’t matter if she didn’t have evidence, everyone would believe her.

“We’ll be expelled for sure,” said Remus. Sirius looked at him and tears were forming in his boyfriend’s eyes.

“No,” quickly replied Sirius. Not entirely sure of what he was going to say. “I’ll handle this.”

Sirius quickly pulled his pants up, wiped the mess off his stomach and jumped out of the bed. He had already envisioned himself chasing down Lily, half naked, through the halls of Hogwarts in the middle of the night. That’s why the marauder was surprised when he found Lily standing only a few feet away from the bed. She was giving him her back.

“Lily?” Sirius said, carefully. He didn’t want to set her off. Again, he wasn’t sure what he was going to say, but he would pull something out of his arse like he always did. “Remus and I…”

“I didn’t know,” she interrupted him.

Sirius wasn’t entirely sure what she was talking about, but he felt like he could take control of the situation. “That we were gay?” he wondered out loud.

Was she chuckling? “So sharp and yet so oblivious at the same time,” she said between chuckles. “That’s Sirius Black in a nutshell.”

Sirius started to think that maybe the shock had made her lose her mind. “That’s surely the first time I’ve heard that, Evans.” He was a bit offended by Lily’s comment.

“I’ve known you two are a couple for a while now,” she explained. “Very little escapes me and you two are not a subtle as you think you are. Especially you, Black. You stare at that boy like you’re about to eat him.”

She got that right, he thought. “So, you’re okay with this?”

“Of course I don’t mind the two of you dating!” she admitted as if she was stating the obvious. “But you two did brake the rules, and gravely.”

“Evans, I promise you we will never…”

Lily dismissed his comment with her hand. “Before you lie, again, Black, I want to make you a proposal. If the two of you do something for me then I will ignore that…incident completely.”

Sirius sighed in relief. They were safe. “We’ll do anything.”

“I’m glad to hear it.” A suspectful grin appeared on Lily’s face. “All I want is to have another, more private round of truth or dare.”

“That’s it?” wondered Sirius out loud, not believing her entirely.

“Yes, that’s it.” She confirmed. “Please bring Remus…Oh, and would you be a darling and wake up James?”

Sirius was already walking towards the bed when he turned around and took a look at her. She obviously had something planned. Remus had popped his head between the curtains of the bed and was looking at Sirius with confusion. He looked so cute, Sirius thought. He shuddered and proceeded to follow madam Evan’s instructions.


***



A few minutes later, the four of them were sitting on the floor. James had protested at first, but soon rose to his feet when Sirius told him Lily was involved. Remus obliged as well, he would do anything to get out of that mess. After all, he was a Headboy too, and if Lily talked he would be in big, big trouble.

Lily summoned a red, round carpet for them to sit on, which was surprisingly comfortable, and cast a couple of spells around them. One of the charms was for them not to be seen and the other for them not to be heard. Peter could wake up and he wouldn’t sense them. Sirius envied Lily’s ability. As soon as the spells were cast Lily lit a candle she had brought from the girls dorm while Sirius was waking James up.

“Sirius, truth or dare?” Lily asked. This was the first time she called him by his first name.

What was that woman thinking? “Dare,” he answered, in a challenging tone.

“Take your trousers off,” she said with a smirk.

Sirius rolled his eyes. He thought it was a ridiculous dare, but then he remembered he wasn’t wearing any underwear. He had left it between the bed’s sheets and Lily probably knew it. That bitch, he thought.

“You don’t have anything we haven’t seen,” teased Lily.

James glanced with confusion from Sirius to Lily several times and since none of them gave him an answer he stared at Remus who rolled his eyes. Confidently, Sirius stood up and started to untie the strap of his pajama pants slowly. What the heck! He didn’t have anything to be embarrassed about. He had a great body and they all had already seen him naked anyway.

James was already covering his eyes and Remus stared nervously at Sirius. Lily watched, interested, but not in a lustful manner. It seemed that for her was more like studying a subject she found fascinating, but didn’t know much about.

After the strap was untied, he inserted both his thumb fingers by the hips and pulled the pants down slowly. If there was something he was good at, it was teasing. He pulled down until the beginning of his black pubic hair was visible, then turned around and flashed his bottom. Before he knew it, he dropped his pants and turned around. His full manhood was hanging for all of them to see. James was staring at the floor, Lily studied him, and for a second Sirius thought he saw Remus lick his lips.

Finally, he sat down. Seeing that Sirius wasn’t going to cover himself, Remus put his hand over his boyfriend’s penis.

“Do you mind giving it a little stroke while you’re at it?” Sirius asked Remus with a grin. Remus instantly flushed, but didn’t remove his hand. Somehow, being naked gave Sirius even more confidence. Suddenly, he remembered it was his turn. He would get that bitch. “Lily, truth or dare?”

Lily thought for a second. “Dare…” she finally said in a low tone. James, who until that point had been staring at the floor, stared at Lily incredulously. He then started at Sirius pleadingly.

Sorry, mate, not just yet.

He leaned back and pushed a pelvis a bit forward against Remus’ palm. He was going to enjoy this. “Lily, I dare you to lick James’ foot.”

Lily and James both stared at Sirius with widened eyes and Remus was trying to hold his laughter.

Lily quickly composed herself. “James, would you be so kind to give me your foot?”

“What?” James obviously wasn’t expecting her to go through with it. “You don’t have to do this!”

“James, I wont ask again!” She was serious. “Give me your bloody foot!”

James shot a dirty look at Sirius and uncrossed his legs, stalling the moment as much as he could. Finally, James’ ankle landed on Lily’s grip. She took a deep breath and in light speed licked the base of the foot.

“No, no, no,” Sirius shook his head. He was expecting this. “You have to enjoy it, or at least pretend. Like I did with my strip.”

Once more time, James and Lily shot nasty looks at Sirius. Lily took another deep breath and licked James foot. This time it was slow and even made some shapes with her tongue. James wasn’t upset anymore; he was looking at her with awe.

“It’s not that bad,” she commented more to herself than to the others. Now it was her turn again. Sirius was sure Lily would pick him in revenge. “Remus, truth or dare?” But he was wrong.

It also took Remus by surprise. “…Truth?” James and Sirius booed him.

“No, no that’s acceptable,” said Lily raising an eyebrow. She wasn’t meaning what she was saying.

“Very well then, I pick dare…” he sighed.

“Lovely!” Lily exclaimed. “I want you to kiss James!”

James gasped and Remus’ jaw almost hit the floor. Suddenly, Sirius heart started beating faster. Watching his boyfriend and his best mate snog was a secret fantasy of his. He never told Remus because he knew his boyfriend would be repelled by the idea, but he still thought about it, and masturbated thinking about it. It was so naughty and forbidden his dick was staring to get hard. Luckily, none of the others noticed.

“I’m out!” James announced and stood up in a jolt.

“No!” Lily cried. “If you do this I promise to make it up to you!”

“How?” James wasn’t so upset anymore, but wasn’t buying it either.

“In ways you’ve only dreamed of.” In a very daring move, Lily unbuttoned her shirt revealing the space between her breasts. James was speechless. He swallowed loudly and sat on the floor, carefully.

“Don’t I get a saying in this?” protested Remus. His hand was still covering Sirius’ privates.

Sirius turned to Remus and mouthed a very clear ‘no’. That seemed to do the trick. With that short word Remus knew Sirius was into the idea. So he gave in. The werewolf leaned in across the circle. James, whose face was red, did the same. The two boys were soon in all four in front of each other.

“If you say anything about this, I’ll kill you,” James threatened.

“Do you think I want to brag about this?” Remus asked. “Let’s just get it over and done with!”

Both boys leaned slowly forward. Sirius was getting harder by the second. He could see Lilly behind the two about-to-kiss-each-other heads and she was breathing loudly. Their lips touched for a few seconds and they pulled away.

“There!” James said, crossing his legs.

“Is that how you want to kiss me?” Lily asked, disappointed. James was surprised with the question. “Because if that’s the case then you can forget about it.”

Remus glanced at Sirius and he raised an eyebrow. “Show him how we do it.” Sirius told him, cockier than ever.

This time James didn’t have time to think. Remus jumped at him and kissed him, fiercely. He took James’ glasses off and put them aside. Before anyone could tell, they were opening their mouths and letting each other’s tongues in. Remus was obviously the one attacking, but James was fighting back.

Sirius couldn’t resist anymore. He grabbed his shaft and started stroking. It was just so hot! Remus had his fingers between James’ hairs and the bespectacled had his hands on Remus back. Sirius almost moaned when Remus bit James’ lower lip. He loved when the werewolf did that to him and apparently also loved to watch him do it to someone else.

Remus pulled away and left James lying on the floor. “That’s…how…I want…to kiss you…” James managed to mumble between breaths.

Remus smiled lustfully when he saw Sirius stroking his cock. He crawled in a feline way up to him and sat on his boyfriend’s lap.

“Did you like that?” he asked, but he already knew the answer. He pulled Sirius hair and gave him a sloppy kiss. His tongue was wilder than ever. That night Remus was truly inspired, Sirius thought. “James, truth or dare?” he asked, not taking his eyes away from Sirius’.

“Dare.” James apparently had managed to regain his breath and was now grinning, nervously.

“James, I want you to kiss Lily,” Remus said into Sirius mouth that was open waiting for another kiss. James was leaning in when Remus interrupted him. “No, no, I don’t want you to kiss her on the lips,” he revealed, finally looking away from Sirius. “I want you to kiss her there.”

Sirius’ eyes widened when he saw that Remus was pointing between Lily’s legs. It just kept getting better and better. James and Lily were frozen with mixed feelings. It was almost as if the game had split into two teams. At one side sat the two nervous pigeons and across sat a werewolf on a horny dog’s lap. Sirius was so proud of his little devil.

Without a word, Lily stood up and removed her knickers. They slid down between her legs and landed on the floor. Nervously, she sat on front of James and after looking away, spread her legs.

“Don’t tell me you’ve never dreamed about it,” Sirius said, grinning.

James didn’t have a choice. Before they knew it, James head was disappearing inside Lily’s skirt. She was flushed and squinted at first and then she started giggling softly. It was bad. It was really bad if your partner laughed when you were giving him or her oral sex. Before Sirius could make a joke, Lily’s face changed drastically.

“OH!” She moaned, loudly.

Sirius could see James head moving slightly inside Lily’s skirt. Lily let her upper body fall to the floor. She had one hand on her mouth and the other teased one of her pink nipples. Her breasts were fully exposed now.

Sirius got hard once more and his dick touched the fabric of Remus’ pajama pants. He felt the sudden urge of ripping them off and fucking Remus right there on the floor. Why not? The night was bizarre enough. He hugged Remus tightly against his chest and leaned to the floor taking the werewolf with him.

“What are you doing?” Remus asked, between chuckles.

“What do you think?” Sirius replied.

He ripped Remus’ pajama’s shirt open and buttons flew everywhere. Then, he proceeded to remove the werewolf’s trousers, which he did swiftly. Remus’ naked, limber body was a lying on the floor waiting for him. Sirius had to have him now. He spread his boyfriend’s legs and placed his cock between the butt cheeks. Once he found the entrance he pushed his pelvis forward with more strength that he intended to. Remus cried in pain.

“Sorry,” Sirius muttered, gaining control of himself. “Are you okay?”

Remus didn’t answer right away. His eyes were closed and it worried Sirius. He was going to ask again when he felt Remus’ hands on his bum. “Don’t worry about me…just keep going,” he whispered.

Sirius didn’t need to hear more. He kissed his boyfriend softly and with one strong thrust he was inside of Remus. The werewolf moaned into Sirius’ mouth. They stayed silent and connected for a while until the Remus’ muscles relaxed.

Remus was on his back and Sirius was on top of him. The werewolf was hugging his boyfriend tightly against him when Sirius started moving his pelvis back and forth. Sirius loved the feeling of Remus’ tight arse around his cock. The more inside he went, the tighter it got. He loved it.

It wasn’t until later, when Sirius’ heard Lily’s moaning that he remembered the other couple. Lily was sitting on top of James and her legs were wrapped around his waste. James caressed her back and kissed her breasts. Was he penetrating her? Sirius couldn’t tell until he saw James bare, skinny legs on the red carpet.

Both couples were making love at the same time. For a second Sirius and James exchanged glances. He never thought he would be in this situation with his best mate. They had both made it.

Sirius’ thoughts were blurred by a sudden wave of carnal pleasure. He was about to come. “Moony…I…” he couldn’t talk anymore. Like a wild animal, he arched his back and howled as he finished inside his partner. He let his sweaty body fall on top of Remus. The werewolf hugged him, but Sirius couldn’t return the hug. He barely felt his arms.

“Have you noticed that when you’re about to come you call me Moony?” Remus whispered into his lover’s ear.

“I wasn’t aware…I said anything,” Sirius uttered and Remus chuckled.

Next to them, James and Lily had apparently also finished. They were frozen for a few seconds, almost embarrassed by what they had just done. Amateurs, Sirius thought. Lily quickly stood up and dressed up as quickly as she could.

“Good night, everyone,” she muttered and rushed out.

James covered his privates and spoke, breaking the silence. “Well…I guess that’s it then.” A bit of sadness invaded his eyes.

Before Sirius or Remus could say anything comforting to their mate, Lily came back, gave James a quick peck on the lips and left as quickly as she had returned.

“No, James,” Remus said. “That’s the beginning.”

Comments

Posted by: waits for nothing (water_jade)
Posted at: October 21st, 2007 02:41 am (UTC)
self-promotion panic style

I loved this line in particular: He wanted to laugh, cry, pass out, and thank Remus for the best fucking blowjob of his life, all at once.

And seriously, as soon as Lily came back the entire story was ridiculously entertaining. Your game of private!truth or dare was very well-concocted. Lovely.

Why not? The night was bizarre enough. So true.

1 Read Comments